The Yankees have a hole in left field after Cody Bellinger opted out of his contract, becoming a free agent. While they could re-sign Bellinger, who hit 29 home runs and played excellent defense, they should consider alternatives to strengthen their roster.
Bellinger's performance in 2025 was valuable, with the Yankees getting excellent value on their $25 million investment. However, this does not necessarily mean his value will remain the same. The team should not confuse his past performance with a potential change in value.
Signing Kyle Tucker could provide the Yankees with the star talent and roster depth needed to create their best team in the Aaron Judge era. Although it may cost more than re-signing Bellinger and could impact future signings, the 2025 season saw significant internal developments that Hal Steinbrenner should invest in.
The signing of Kyle Tucker could give them the star talent and roster depth to have their best team in the Aaron Judge era.
Author's summary: Yankees should pursue Kyle Tucker for roster depth.